TRANSCRIPT OF A RECORDING OF A
TELEPHONE CONVERSATION BETWEEN
JOHN EHRLICHMAN AND HERBERT KALMBACH
APRIL 19, 1973
EHRLICHMAN: How are you?
KALMBACH: I’m, I’m pretty good.
KALMBACH: I’m, I’m, uh, scheduled for two tomorrow afternoon.
EHRLICHMAN: Where, at the jury or the U.S. Attorney?
KALMBACH: At the jury.
KALMBACH: …and I’m scheduled at 5:30 this afternoon with, uh, with Silbert.
EHRLICHMAN: Oh, are ya?
KALMBACH: Yeah. I uh, just wanted to run through quickly
KALMBACH: …several things, John, in line with our conversation. I, I uh, got in
here and, uh, last night and there’s a telephone call from O’Brien. I returned it
and went over there today. And uh, he said the reason that was–for the call– was
La Rue had told him that to ask him to call me to say that he’d had to identify
KALMBACH: …in connection with this, and, uh, and he wanted me to know that, and
EHRLICHMAN: Did he tell you about Dean?
APRIL 19, 1973 2
EHRLICHMAN: Well, Dean has, uh, totally cooperated with the U.S. Attorney in the
hopes of getting immunity.
KALMBACH: Um hum.
EHRLICHMAN: Now what he says, or how he says it, nobody seems to be able to divine.
EHRLICHMAN: But he’s…
KALMBACH: The whole enchilada?
EHRLICHMAN: He’s throwing off on Bob and me heavily.
KALMBACH: He is?
KALMBACH: He is?
EHRLICHMAN: And taking the position that he was a mere agent.
KALMBACH: Um hum.
EHRLICHMAN: Now, on your episode…
KALMBACH: Yes, sir.
EHRLICHMAN: …he told me before he left, so to speak, –he, Dean–told me that
really my transaction with him involving you was virtually my only area of liability
in this thing. And I said, “Well John, what in the world are you talking about?”
He said, “Well I came to you for Mitchell and I said, uh, Mitchell needs money.
Uh, could we call Herb Kalmbach and ask him to raise some?” And I said–and, and,
Dea– says to me–and you said yes.
APRIL 19, 1973 3
EHRLICHMAN: And I said, “Yes, that’s right.”And he said,
(CONT.) “Well, that does it.” And I said, “Well, that’s hard for me to believe.
I don’t understand the law
KALMBACH: Um hum.
EHRLICHMAN: “…but I don’t think Herb entered into this with any guilty intent…
KALMBACH: I know
EHRLICHMAN: “…and I, I certainly didn’t.” And so I said, “I just find that hard
to imagine.” Now since then I have retained counsel.
KALMBACH: Oh, you have?
EHRLICHMAN: Who is very good and who agrees with me that it is the remotest kind
EHRLICHMAN: But uh, the, the, point that I think has to be clarified, that I’m going
to clarify if I get a chance, is that the reason that Dean had to come to me and
to Bob where you were concerned is that we had promised you that you would not be
run pillar to post by Maury Stans.
KALMBACH: And also, and, and also that you knew — I was your friend–and you knew
I was the President’s attorney
KALMBACH: …and never do anything improper
KALMBACH: …illegal, unethical, or whatever.
KALMBACH: And uh …
APRIL 19, 1973 4
EHRLICHMAN: But the, the point is that rather than Mitchell calling you direct,
Mitchell knew darn well that you were no longer available.
EHRLICHMAN: Now this was post-April 6th, was it not?
KALMBACH: April 7th.
EHRLICHMAN: Yeah. So that, uh, Mitchell and Stans both knew that there wasn’t any
point in their calling you direct because we had gotten you out of that on the pretext
that, uh, you were going to do things for us.
KALMBACH: That’s right.
EHRLICHMAN: And so, uh, uh, it was necessary for Dean to come to me and then in
turn to Bob, and, and plead a very urgent case without really getting into any specifics,
except to say you have to trust me, this is very important. And, uh, Mitchell is
up his tree, or you know, I mean is really worked up” he didn’t. use that phrase–“but
is, is really exercised about this.”
KALMBACH: Um hum.
EHRLICHMAN: I said, “Well, John, if you tell me it’s that important, why yes.”
KALMBACH: You know when you and I, when you and I talked, and it was after John
had given me that, that word, and I came in to say–ask you, uh, “John, is this
an assignment I have to take on”, and you said, “Yes, it is.” Uh, period. And uh…
EHRLICHMAN: Um hum.
APRIL 19, 1973 5
KALMBACH: …go forward. Then that was all that I needed to be assured that I wasn’t
putting my family in jeopardy.
KALMBACH: And I would, I would just understand that, uh, you and I are absolutely
together on that.
EHRLICHMAN: No question about it, uh, Herb, that I would never knowingly have put
you in any kind of a spot.
KALMBACH: Yeah. Well, and when you and–when we talked, you knew what I was about
to do, you know–to go out and get some dough for this purpose. I mean the humanitarian
KALMBACH: And uh…
EHRLICHMAN: It was a defense fund.
KALMBACH: …and a defense fund.
EHRLICHMAN: Yeah, Yeah.
KALMBACH: …and to, to, to support the families.
EHRLICHMAN: That’s it.
KALMBACH: Now, uh, the thing that was disquieting about this thing with, uh, with
O’Brien was that, uh, he said,” there is a massive campaign evidently underway to
indict all the lawyers, including, including you, Herb.” And I just was a little
KALMBACH: …that. And I guess what, what I need to get from you, John, is assurance
that this is not true.
APRIL 19, 1973 6
EHRLICHMAN: Well, I don’t know of any attempt to target you at all.
EHRLICHMAN: My hunch is that they’re trying to get at me. The’re trying to corroborate.
See, what they’ve said to Dean is that he gets no consideration from them unless
they can corroborate Haldeman and my liability.
KAUMBACH: God, if I, I can just make it plain that uh, the–it was the humanitarian
and no nothing else.
EHRLICHMAN: Yeah. And, and the point, uh, uh_that I undoubtedly never expressed
to you-that I continually operated on the basis of Dean’s representations to me.
EHRLICHMAN: And I had the, uh
KALMBACH: It was not improper.
KALMBACH: And there, uh, was nothing illegal about it.,
EHRLICHMAN: Right. See he’s the house lawyer.
KALMBACH: Yup. Exactly. And I just couldn’t believe in – you would – you and Bob
and the President’s just too good, too good friends to ever put me in the position
where I’m putting my family on the line.
EHRLICHMAN: Why of course.
KALMBACH: And, uh, it’s, it’s just unbelievable, un… unthinkable. Now, uh, shall
I just-I’ll just, uh – if I’m asked by this Silbert, I’ll just lay it out just exactly
APRIL 19, 1973 7
EHRLICHMAN: Yeah. I wouldn’t haul the President into it…
KALMBACH: Oh, no, no, no
EHRLICHMAN: If you can help it.
KALMBACH: I will not. No.
EHRLICHMAN: But uh, I think the point that uh, uh, which I will make in the future,
uh-if I’m given the chance that, uh, you are not under our control in any sort of
a slavery sense…
KALMBACH: No, but
EHRLICHMAN: … but that we had agreed that, ah,you would not be at the beck and
call of the Committee.
KALMBACH: And, and, of course too, that I respond only on orders and, you know,
on direction, and uh, if this is something that you felt sufficiently important
and, uh, that-you were, that you were as, as, assured was altogether proper, then
I would take it on because I always do it, and always have. And you and Bob and
the President know that.
EHRLICHMAN: Yeah. Well, uh, uh, as far as propriety is concerned, I think we both
were relying entirely on Dean.
EHRLTCHMAN: I made no independent judgment…
KALMBACH: Yep. Yep.
EHRLICHMAN: And I am sure Bob didn’t either.
APRIL 19, 1973 8
KALMBACH: No. And, I just-I’m just – I just have the feeling, John that, it, uh,
I don’t know whether this is a weak reed. Is it?
EHRLICHMAN: For who, Dean?
KALMBACH: No. I mean this-for-I mean are they still going to say, “Well, Herb, you
should have known?”
EHRLICHMAN: I don’t know how you could. You, you didn’t make any inquiries.
KALMBACH: Never. And the only inquiries I made,John, was to you
KALMBACH: after, after I talked to, to John Dean.
EHRLICHMAN: And you found that I didn’t know just a whole hell of a lot.
KALMBACH: Yes, but you said this is something T,I have to do, and I
EHRLICHMAN: Well, yeah. And the reason that I said that, as you know, was not from
any I personal inquiry, but was on the basis of, uh what had been represented to
KALMBACH: Yeah. And, and to, uh provide the defense fund and to, to take care of
the families of these fellows who were, uh, then
KALMBACH: …who had not then been found neither quilty
or not guilty.
EHRLICHMAN: But, and the point being here, without attempting them-to induce them
to do a damn thing.
KALMBACH: Absolutely not. And that was never – that was exactly right.
APRIL 19, 1973 9
KALMBACH: Now, can I, can I get in to see you tomorrow before I go in there at two?
EHRLICHMAN: If you want to. Now they’ll, they’ll ask you.
KALMBACH: Will they?
KALMBACH: Well, maybe I sho… maybe I shouldn’t.
EHRLICHMM: They’ll ask you to whom you’ve spoken about your testimony. And I would
appreciate it if you would say that you talked to me in California, because at that
time, I was investigating this thing for the President.
KALMBACH: And not now?
EHRLICHMAN: Uh, well, I wouldn’t ask you to lie
KALMBACH: No, I know
EHRLICHMAN: Uh, but the point is…
KALMBACH: Not — but the testimony was in California?
EHRLICHMAN: The point is – well, no. I mean your recollection of, of, facts and
KALMBACH: Yes, I agree.
EHRLICHMAN: See, uh, uh, I don’t think we were ever seen together out there, but,
but at some point I am going to have to say that I talked to O’Brien and Dean and,
uh, Magruder and Mitchell and you, and a whole lot of people about this case.
APRIL 19, 1973 10
EHRLICHMAN: And so, uh, uh, uh, it, it would be consistent
KALMBACH: Now, do you, do you feel, John-calling a big shot here – do you, do you
feel, assured, as you did when, when we were out there that, that there’s no culpability
KALMBACH: And nothing to worry about
EHRLTCHMAN: And Herb, from everything I hear, they’re not after you.
KALMBACH: Yes, sir.
EHRLICHMAN: From everything I hear.
KALMBACH: Well, I (unintelligible) Barbara, you know, I just
EHRLICHMAN: They’re out to get me and they’re out to get Bob.
KALMBACH: My God. All right. Well, John, I’ll-it’ll be absolutely clear that there
was no – there was nothing, uh, looking towards any cover-up or anything.
KALMBACH: It was just strictly from humanitarian and,uh, and I just wanted you,
I just_when I talked to you–I just wanted you to advise me that it was all right
on that, on that basis
EHRLICHMAN: On that basis.
KALMBACH: to go forward.
EHRLICHMAN: That it was necessary…
APRIL 19, 1973 11
KALMBACH: And that will be precisely the way it is.
EHRLICHAMAN: Thanks, Herb.